David Ackroyd

Self - Narrator

Arthur Kent

Self - Host

Joel Martin

Self - Author and Paranormal Expert

Kathy Lutz

Self - Former Owner / Occupant, 112 Ocean Ave.

George Lutz

Self - Former Owner / Occupant, 112 Ocean Ave.

William Weber

Self - Attorney

Hans Holzer

Self - Parapsychologist / Author

Harvey Aronson

Self - Co-Author High Hopes: The Amityville Murders

Laura DiDio

Self - Reporter / Researcher

Lorraine Warren

Self - New England Soc. for Psychical Research

Ed Warren

Self - New England Soc. for Psychial Research

Marvin Scott

Self - Newscaster

Roxanne Salch Kaplan

Self - Co-Author The Amityville Horror Conspiracy

Chief Straight Arrow

Self - Montaukett Tribe of Long Island

Jay Anson

Self (Archival Footage)